September 22 – The fate of the Live Bait Squadron

Pasted Graphic

On this day in 1914 three Cressy class ships of “The Live Bait Squadron” were attacked and sunk. At least twenty men from Northern Ireland were lost in this engagement.

During the early months of World War 1 the Royal Navy maintained a patrol of old Cressy class armoured cruisers, known as Cruiser Force C, in the area of the North Sea known as the Broad Fourteens. It was nicknamed ‘The Live Bait Squadron’. The three Cressy class ships were sunk in a matter of minutes with the loss of 60 officers and 1,400 men. It was to be the first of two major actions within three weeks which announced the arrival of the U Boat and the impact submarines could have on naval warfare. An account of the action follows the Rolls of Honour.

HMS ABOUKIR ROLL OF HONOUR

Pasted Graphic 3

+CLELAND, Matthew
RN. Stoker 1st Class. SS105670. HMS Aboukir. Died 22/09/1914. Aged 23. Enrolled 23/08/1907 for 5 and 7 years. Served to 24/08/1912. Joined RFR 25/08/1912. In Aboukir for mobilisation test 18/07/1914 – 25/07/1914, Pembroke and Aboukir 29/07/1914 – 22/09/1914. Born Belfast 18/02/1888. Son of James Cleland, Beersbridge Rd., Belfast. Chatham Naval Memorial. ADM 188/1111/105670

DONNELLY, H
RN. Stoker I. SS105635. HMS Aboukir. Died 22/09/1914. Age 26. Enrolled 06/08/1907 for 5 and 7 years. Served to 03/08/1912. Joined RFR 04/08/1912. Served 13/07/1914 – 22/09/1914, Pembroke II and Aboukir. Born Belfast 28/01/1888. College Square North, Belfast. IMR. ADM 188/1111/105635

+EVERALL, Edward Henry
RN. AB. 233891. HMS Aboukir. Died 22/09/1914. Aged 25. Boy service from 18/05/1905. Enrolled 16/11/1906 for 12 years. War service in Egmont, Blenheim, Sutlej, Pembroke and Aboukir (31/07/1914 – 22/09/1914). Died 22/09/1914. Born Annalong 16/11/1888. Son of Freeman and Ellen Everall, of 19, Vale View Rd., Dover. Chatham Naval Memorial. ADM 188/414/233891

+FOSTER, John
RN. Stoker 1st Class. SS/104740. HMS Aboukir. Died 22/09/1914. Age 27. Enrolled 08/03/1907 for 5 and 7years. Served to 09/03/1912. Joined RFR 10/03/1912. Served 17/07/1914 – 22/09/1914. In Aborukir from 29/08/1914. Born Dromore, Co.Down 06/09/1887. Son of Archie and Jane Foster, Spring St., Belfast. Chatham Naval Memorial, Panel 5. Belfast Corporation RH. ADM 188/1110/104740

+GORDON, William James
RN. Stoker 1st Class. HMS Aboukir. Died 22/09/1914. Enrolled 18/03/1906 for 5 and 7 years. Served to 17/03/1911. Joined RFR 18/03/1911. Served from 13/07/1914. In Pembroke and Aborukir (29/07/1914 – 22/09/1914). Quoile, Saul. Downpatrick WM

+KERR, William Johnston
RN. Stoker 1st Class. SS105934. HMS Aboukir. Died 22/09/1914. Age 25. Served 16/10/1907 – 19/10/1912. Joined RFR 20/10/1912. In Aborukir (Test Mob.) 13/07/1914 – 25/07/1914, Pembroke II, and Aborukir 28/07/1914 – 22/09/1914. Born Belfast 11/08/1889. Son of John Kerr, Temple St., Belfast, and the late Mary Kerr. Chatham Naval Memorial. ADM 188/1111/105934

+MARTIN, William
RN. Stoker 1st Class. K11808. HMS Aboukir. Died 22/09/1914. Age 22. Aborukir sank in action with submarine in North Sea. Enrolled 22/07/1911 for 12 years. War service in Hecla and Aborukir (09/08/1914 – 22/09/1914). Born Belfast 05/05/1893. Son of William and Ellen Martin, Belfast; husband to Isabella Martin, Waterford St., Belfast. Chatham Naval Memorial. ADM 188/890/11808

+McBRIDE, Gilbert
Stoker 1st Class. SS103628. HMS Aboukir . Died 22/09/1914. Age 26. Enrolled 22/08/1906 for 5 and 7 years. Served to 18/08/1911. Joined RFR 19/08/1911. Served from 13/07/1914 in Pembroke and Aborukir 29/07/1914 – 22/09/1914. Born Belfast 31/01/1888. Son of Elizabeth McBride, Mayflower St., Beersbridge Rd., Belfast, and the late William McBride; husband to the late Sarah McBride. Chatham Naval Memorial. IRM. ADM 188/1109/103628

+SANDS, Hugh
RN. Stoker 1st Class. SS/109990. HMS Aboukir. Died 22/09/1914. Age 24. Son of the late John and Mary Sands. Fortingale St., Belfast. Chatham Naval Memorial, Panel 5

+QUINN, T
RN. SS/100714. HMS Aboukir. Died 22/09/1914. Age 29. Son of Thomas and Susan Quinn; husband of Annie Quinn, Avoniel St., Belfast. Chatham Naval Memorial, Panel 5.

HMS CRESSY ROLL OF HONOUR

Pasted Graphic 1

The Cressy was a prototype of a class of six heavily armoured cruisers which when finished would be among the most powerful ships of their class. She was the first of the Cressy Class to be built. Built at Fairfield at Govan on the Clyde and laid down on the 12th |October 1898, launched 4th December 1899 and completed 28th May 1901. On completion HMS Cressy went to the China station. and In 1906-1907 Cressy went to the North American and West Indies station as Boy  training ship. In August 1909 joined the 3rd Fleet at the Nore  until April 1910 when she went to Chatham and into reserve. In January 1911 joined the 4th Division of the home fleet. and In August 1914 joined Cruiser Force C. Torpedoed and sunk by U -9 on 22nd September 1914 while picking up survivors of HMS Aboukir. 560 lives was lost out of 760. Sister ships were HMS Aboukir, HMS Bacchante, HMS Euryalus, HMS Hogue and HMS Sutlej.

+CHANCELLOR, Samuel
RN. Stoker 1st. Class. SS110580. HMS Cressy. Died 22/09/1914. Age 22. Enrolled 03/01/1911 for 5 and 7 years. In Cressy 05/06/1912 – 22/09/1914. Born Belfast 07/11/1892. Son of John and Emily Chancellor, Belfast. Chatham Naval Memorial. IMR. ADM 188/1116/110580

+HILLAND, Joseph
RN. Stoker I. SS106892. HMS Cressy. Died 22/09/1914. Age 24. Enrolled 19/03/1908 for 5 and 7 years. Served to 18/03/1913. Joined RFR 19/03/1913. Served from 25/07/1914. In Cressy 29/07/1914 – 22/09/1914. Born Belfast 09/03/1890. Son of John and Esther Hilland; husband to Eliza Jane Hilland, Renfrew St., Belfast. Gravenzande General Cemetery, Zuid-Holland, Netherlands. Great Victoria Street – PCI RH. IMR. ADM 188/1112/106892

+HUGHES, Thomas Joseph
RN. Stoker 1st Cl. SS103750. HMS Cressy. Died 22/09/1914. Age 29. Enrolled 10/09/1906 for 5 and 7 years. Served to 09/09/1911. Joined RFR 10/09/1911. Served from 25/07/1914 in Pembroke II and Cressy (29/07/1914 – 22/09/1914). Born Belfast 01/10/1885. Son of James Hughes; husband to Mary Ann Hughes, Dunville St., Belfast. Chatham Naval Memorial. ADM 188/1109/103750

+LOGAN, John
SS106972. Stoker 1st Class. HMS Cressy. Died 22/09/1914. Age 24. Enrolled 21/04/1908 for 5 and 7 years. Served to 19/03/1913. Joined RFR 20/03/1913. In Pembroke 25 – 28/07/1914 and Cressy 29/07/19114 – 22/09/1914. Born Belfast 22/01/1890. Son of Henry and Sarah Logan, Upper Meadow St., Belfast. Chatham Naval Memorial.

+MARSHALL, Isaiah
RN. Stoker 1st Class. SS/106977. HMS Cressy. Died 22/09/1914. Enrolled 22/04/1908 for 5 and 7 years. Served to 19/04/1913. Joined RFR 20/04/1913. Served in Pembroke 25/08/1914 – 28/08/1914 and Cressy 29/08/1914 – 22/09/1914. Born Belfast 02/02/1890. City St., Belfast. Chatham Naval Memorial, Panel 5. ADM 188/1112/106977

+McMURRAN, Henry
RN. Stoker 1st Class. SS103004. HMS Cressy. Died 22/09/1914. Age 27. Served 21/05/1906 – 24/05/1911. Joined RFR 27/05/1911. War service in Pembroke II and Cressy (24/07/1914 – 22/09/1914). Born Whitehead 13/03/1887. Son of James and Margaret McMurran, Sullatober, Carrickfergus. He was a member of Sullatober Flute band. Another member, Stoker Andrew McAllister was lost three weeks later in HMS Hawke. Chatham Naval Memorial, Panel 5. Carrickfergus WM. ADM 188/1109/103004

+NEILL, Charles
RN. Stoker I. SS106586. HMS Cressy. Died 22/09/1914. Age 26. Born Belfast 16/12/1889. Son of the late Mr. and Mrs. W. Neill, of Belfast; husband to Annie Anderson White (formerly Neill), York Rd., Belfast. Chatham Naval Memorial. IMR

+REDMOND, William Joseph
RN. Stoker 1st Class. SS/104015. HMS Cressy. Died 22/9/1914. Age 29. Husband of Annie Redmond, Gracehill St., Belfast. Chatham Naval Memorial, Panel 5

+SINGLETON, Joshua. 
RN. Leading Carpenters Crew. 345952. HMS Cressy. Died 22/09/1914. Age 37. Born Hillsborough 09/08/1877. Son of David and Eliza Jane Singleton, and husband to Elizabeth Singleton, Railway View, Culcavey, Hillsborough. Chatham Naval Memorial, Panel 6. Hillsborough WM. ADM 188/524/345952

+WRIGHT, William
RNR. CERA. 425EB. HMS Cressy. Died 22/09/1914. Husband to Sarah Wright, Glenrosa St., Belfast. Leslie J Thompson Masonic Lodge 61, Ballymacarrett, Belfast.Portsmouth Naval Memorial, Panel 6. Rosemary Street – PCI RH

Pasted Graphic 2
A door of the Cressy was recovered. It is very impressive. It is made of solid wood, so it may have served as a lifebuoy and perhaps saved someone’s life.

According to a Welsh tradition, Edward I promised to provide Wales with a prince “who could speak no word of English,” and when his son Edward of Carnarvon was born he presented him to the assembly, saying in Welsh Eich dyn (behold the man).
The more general belief is that it was the motto under the plume of John, King of Bohemia, slain by the Black Prince at Cressy in 1346, and that the Black Prince who slew the Bohemian assumed it out of modesty, to indicate that “he served under the king his father.” – Cobham Brewer’s, Dictionary of Phrase and Fable

HMS HOGG ROLL OF HONOUR

+CLAIR, William
RNR. Seaman. 1406U. HMS Hogue. Died 22/09/1914. Ardmore Ave., Belfast. Family memorial, Ballylinney Old Graveyard, Co. Antrim. Cooke Centenary – PCI RH. Chatham Naval Memorial, Panel 8

+GRAHAM, David
RN. Stoker I. 307260. HMS Hogue. Died 22/09/1914. Age 36. Killed in action with submarine in North Sea. Enrolled 04/08/1904 for 12 years. War service in St. George, Pembroke I and Hogue (02/08/1914 – 22/09/1914). Born Whiteabbey 10/07/1881. Son of David and Lizzie Graham, Whiteabbey, Belfast. Chatham Naval Memorial. ADM 188/501/307260

THE SHIPS AND THE ACTION

All these ships were long past retirement. They had been in reserve until the outbreak of the war prompted their recall to service, crewed mostly by reservists. Newer, faster cruisers were not yet ready. The Cressys were despatched to that area of the North Sea known as the Broad Fourteens.

There was opposition to this patrol from many senior officers, including Admiral Jellicoe and Commodores Keyes and Tyrwhitt, on the grounds that the ships were very vulnerable to a raid by modern German surface ships and the patrol was nick named the “live bait squadron”. The Admiralty maintained the patrol on the grounds that destroyers were not able to maintain the patrol in the frequent bad weather and that there were insufficient modern light cruisers available.

So, outdated vessels were accompanied by outdated thinking. In the early hours of 20th September 1914. the cruisers HMS Euryalus, HMS Aboukir, HMS Hogue and HMS Cressy were preparing to go on patrol under Rear Admiral Christian in Euryalus. Normally the patrol was under command of Rear Admiral Campbell in HMS Bacchantes but he was absent so Christian helped fill the gap although he had other duties.

The seas off the Dutch coast had been choppy for several days. The squadron’s commander felt it was choppy enough to deter any U-boat threat. Submarines did not operate in such weather. The old cruisers did not zigzag.

The weather was too bad for destroyers to be at sea and unfortunately Euryalus had to drop out due to lack of coal and weather damage to her wireless, Rear Admiral Christian had to remain with his ship rather than transfer to another ship as the weather was too bad to transfer.

He delegated command to Captain Drummond in Aboukir although he did not make it clear that Drummond had the authority to order the destroyers to sea if the weather improved, which it did towards the end of 21st September.

Early on 22nd September 1914 the German submarine U9 under the command of Commander Otto Weddigen sighted the Cressy, Aboukir and Hogue steaming NNE at 10 knots without zigzagging. Although the patrols were supposed to maintain 12-13 knots and zigzag, the old cruisers were unable to maintain that speed and the zigzagging order was widely ignored as there had been no submarines sighted in the area during the war. They steamed side-by-side 2,000 yards apart and at a modest 10 knots.

Twenty four miles from the Dutch port of Schevingen, U-boat 9 was brought to the surface under command of Kapitanleutenant Otto Weddingen. His 500 tonne boat had ridden out the heavy seas fifty feet down.

The German army, aware of the apparently unhindered shipping of men and materiel between Britain and Ostend had put pressure on their navy.

U9 was on the surface recharging its batteries and its second-in-command Johannes Spiess spotted smoke and a mast. The boat dived. Through its periscope Weddingen saw not one but the three four funneled ships.

U9 manoeuvred to attack and at about 6.25 am., U9 launched a single torpedo at Aboukir, from a range of only 550 yards which thirty odd seconds later stuck her on her port side. Aboukir rapidly suffered heavy flooding and despite counter flooding developed a 20 degree list and lost engine power. It was soon clear that she was a lost cause and Captain Drummond ordered her to be abandoned, although only one boat had survived the attack so most crew had to jump into the sea.

At first Drummond thought that Aboukir had been mined and signalled the other two cruisers to close and assist but he soon realised that it was a torpedo attack and ordered the other cruisers away, but too late.

As Aboukir rolled over and started to disappear, half an hour after being attacked, U9 fired two torpedoes at HMS Hogue that hit her amidships and rapidly flooded her engine room. Captain Nicholson of Hogue had stopped the ship to lower boats to rescue the crew of Aboukir, thinking that as he was the other side of Aboukir from U9 he would be safe. Unfortunately U9 had manoeuvred around Aboukir and attacked Hogue from a range of only 300 yards.

The firing of two torpedoes affected the trim of U9 which broke the surface briefly and was fired on by Hogue without effect. The torpedoes according to an eye-witness nearly cut Hogue on half and the No. 3 funnel collapsed like a house of cards. In five minutes the upper decks of Hogue were being lapped by the sea.

It only took Hogue ten minutes to sink as U9 headed for HMS Cressy. Cressy, under Captain Johnson, had also stopped to lower boats but got underway on sighting a periscope. However at about 7.20 am. U9 fired two torpedoes, one of which just missed but the other hit Cressy on her starboard side, Cressy briefly firing on U9s periscope with no effect.

The damage to Cressy was not fatal but U9 turned round and fired her last torpedo which hit Cressy sinking her within a quarter of an hour. Before the Harwich force of light cruisers and destroyers arrived, survivors were picked up by several nearby merchant ships including the Dutch Flora and Titan and the British trawlers JGC and Corainder. Flora returned to Holland with 286 rescued crew who were quickly returned to Britain even though the neutral Dutch should have interned them. A survivor, Donald Hickman, said they were seen as heroes and treated with great kindness. In all 837 men were rescued but 1459 died, many of which were reservists or cadets.

In the aftermath of the attack the patrol by armoured cruisers was abandoned, the stopping of major ships in dangerous waters banned and the order to steam at 13 knots and zigzag re-emphasised. A court of inquiry was set up and found that some blame was attributable to all of the senior officers involved – Captain Drummond for not zigzagging and for not calling for destroyers, Rear Admiral Christian was criticised for not making it clear to Drummond that he could summon the destroyers and Rear Admiral Campbell for not being present and for a very poor performance at the inquiry at which he stated that he did not know what the purpose of his command was. The bulk of the blame was directed at the Admiralty for persisting with a patrol that was dangerous and of limited value against the advice of senior sea going officers.

The following are the numbers saved from each ship:-
Aboukir, 17 officers, 237 men; total 254.  Cressy, 14 officers, 190 men; total 204.  Hogue, 29 officers, 352 men; total 381.  Totals 60 officers, 779 men.  Grand total, 839.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.